I love Evanescence... but they are not gothic or symphonic metal. They are more emo rock... mixed with a little Christian influence. Sharon whatever-her-last-name-is actually does have a very strong voice, she is able to overpower the rest of the band while still being able to sound mysical and breathy. Now, I can\'t tell you to like her voice \'cause that is your own decision. I however think her voice goes very well. It gives them a very unique sound that only they have. Oh, they are Symphonic Metal, not melodic, not gothic. Although they do have slight gothic tendencies in their music. But Nightwish and Epica are really amazing too! ^_^ I LOVE THEM!