Literalism really hurts your logic as well as your side of the arguement. Not only would every one of those 5,000 (as the OP claims) come back claiming Evolution over Creationism, but there are many factors that separate Evolution and the Bible wrongly. For starters, the time frame of a DAY. From what i've last heard, the 24 hour calender is a very modern definition of a day. I'm no expert, but the definition of time has changed from age to age, until now scientists...the SAME scientists that favor EVOLUTION have come up with Revolutions and Rotations around the Sun to determine our map through day and night. My point? Genesis was more than likely on a whole different time frame than our modern world.