I saw it and I was pretty disappointed. Now, given, I only watched it because it featured Switchfoot's music, but... Crappy, overly sappy love story. Everyone called it cute and innocent but I found the morality of both leading characters to be questionable, and the fact that everyone received it so well kind of bothered me. I hate Shane West as an actor and neither he nor Mandy Moore seemed very comfortable in their roles. The ending was shameless melodrama contrived to incite tears from impressionable movie-goers. Her rendition of Only Hope was the only real highlight. 3/10